Walk into True Value Irving New York—known locally as ADD Lumber—and you’ll immediately realize this isn't some sterile, big-box warehouse where the employees hide in the lumber aisle to avoid helping you. It's actually the opposite. This place is a staple of Chautauqua County, sitting right on Route 5 & 20, and it has a bit of a reputation as the "Irving Mall."
That nickname isn't just a joke. It’s because if you stand in the plumbing aisle for more than ten minutes, you’re almost guaranteed to run into a neighbor, a former teacher, or that guy who fixed your roof three years ago.
Honestly, people usually get two things wrong about this location. First, they think it’s just a tiny "corner store" because it carries the True Value name. It’s not. We’re talking about 27,000 square feet of space. Second, folks assume that because the national True Value parent company went through a massive bankruptcy and sale to Do it Best in late 2024, local stores like the one in Irving are in trouble.
They aren't.
✨ Don't miss: Rite Aid New Castle DE: What’s Actually Left After the Bankruptcy Shakeup
The independent owners, the Dziduch family, run this ship. Like most local hardware hubs, they own the dirt and the inventory. The "True Value" part is basically just the brand on the sign and the logistics network that brings in the hammers and the mulch.
The Weird History of the "Irving Mall"
You’ve got to appreciate the hustle behind this place. It wasn't always the massive hardware superstore it is today. Years ago, it was Smith’s True Value. When Andy Dziduch and his family took over, they didn't just slap a new coat of paint on the walls. They did a full-scale remodel back in 2018 that essentially doubled down on the idea that Irving needed a one-stop shop for building materials.
Why does that matter to you in 2026?
Because in a world where you have to wait three days for a specialized bolt to arrive from an online giant, having a place that actually stocks 85,000 different products within driving distance of the Cattaraugus Reservation and Silver Creek is a lifesaver. It’s about the "I need this right now" factor.
What’s Actually Inside?
If you're heading down there, don't expect a maze. It’s laid out pretty logically, though the sheer volume of stuff can be overwhelming if you're just looking for a single lightbulb.
- Lumber and Building Materials: This is their bread and butter. It’s not just plywood; it’s the heavy-duty stuff for contractors.
- Lawn and Garden: In the spring, this section is basically the town square.
- The Specialized Stuff: They have deep inventory in plumbing and electrical that usually puts the smaller "express" hardware stores to shame.
The hours are pretty standard for a working man's store. They open early at 7:00 AM every day except Sunday (when they open at 9:00 AM), which is great if you’re trying to finish a project before the sun gets too high or the game starts.
The 2024 Bankruptcy Scare: What Really Happened
Let’s clear the air on the "corporate" side of things. In October 2024, True Value Company (the wholesaler) filed for Chapter 11. It made a lot of headlines. People in Irving started asking if their local store was closing.
The short answer: No.
The long answer: The wholesaler was bought by Do it Best Corp. for about $153 million. This was actually a strategic move to stabilize the supply chain. Because True Value Irving New York is independently owned, the bankruptcy didn't touch their bank accounts or their deed. If anything, being part of the Do it Best network now—which is the world’s largest hardware cooperative—means they have more buying power than they did before.
It’s a bit of "inside baseball" business talk, but it basically ensures that the shelves stay full.
Why Irving Matters More Than Dunkirk or Westfield
The Dziduch family actually has a few locations, including spots in Dunkirk and Westfield. But the Irving location—Add Lumber—is the powerhouse. It serves as a bridge between the rural farms and the lakeside communities.
You’ll see a professional contractor loading up a flatbed with 2x4s right next to a grandmother buying a single pot of geraniums. That mix is rare.
One thing most people overlook is the expert advice. You can go to a big-box store in Buffalo and ask how to fix a leaking PVC pipe, and you might get a teenager who was working in the garden center yesterday. At the Irving True Value, you're usually talking to someone who has actually built a deck or wired a house. That "tribal knowledge" is the real value, pun intended.
Surprising Facts About the Store
- The Scale: 27,000 square feet is massive for a town the size of Irving.
- The Ownership: It’s a family-run operation under the ADD Lumber umbrella.
- The Reach: It’s a primary supplier for many local contractors who don't want to drive thirty miles to a larger city.
How to Get the Most Out of Your Visit
If you’re planning a trip to True Value Irving New York, don't just walk in blind.
First, check the weather. If it’s a Saturday morning in May, the place will be packed. If you need a complex lumber order cut, try to go on a Tuesday or Wednesday morning. The staff will have more time to help you pick through the pile for the straightest boards.
Second, use their "Ship-to-Store" option. If they don't have a specific weird tool in stock, you can order it online and have it sent there for free. It saves you the shipping cost and gives you an excuse to browse the aisles anyway.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Project
- Call Ahead: If you need a specific amount of treated lumber, call (716) 934-4238. They can tell you exactly what’s on the lot so you don’t waste a trip.
- Ask for the Pro Desk: If you’re doing a major renovation, don't just grab a cart. Talk to the folks at the building materials desk. They can often help with bulk pricing or delivery schedules.
- Check the Clearance: Because they have so much floor space, they often have "manager specials" on end-caps that aren't advertised online.
The reality is that True Value Irving New York is more than a store; it’s a local resource that survived the collapse of its corporate namesake by being smarter and more connected to the community than the suits in Chicago. Whether you're fixing a sink or building a barn, it’s the place to go.
Go early, grab what you need, and maybe say hi to a neighbor while you're at it.
To get started on your next home improvement task, create a detailed materials list and call the Irving location to verify current inventory levels for lumber and specialized hardware before you make the drive.