You’re sitting at the Thanksgiving table or maybe you’re just grabbing a coffee with an old friend from high school, and then it happens. They mention the border. Or "the steal." Or maybe they just drop a comment about how much better gas prices were four years ago. Your heart rate spikes. Your palms get a little sweaty. You want to scream, but you also kind of want to finish your pie in peace. Knowing what to say to a trumper isn't just about winning a debate—honestly, it’s about survival in a country that feels like it’s split right down the middle.
We've all been there.
Communication experts and psychologists have spent the last decade practically obsessing over this dynamic. It’s not just about politics; it’s about neural pathways and how our brains handle "tribal" threats. Dr. Peter Coleman, who runs the Difficult Conversations Lab at Columbia University, says that when we get into these high-stakes political arguments, we fall into "conflict traps." We stop hearing words and start hearing signals of "friend" or "foe." If you want to actually have a conversation, you have to break that trap first.
Why Facts Usually Backfire (And What to Do Instead)
You probably think that if you just show them the right chart or a specific court ruling, they'll see the light. They won't. There’s this annoying thing called "the backfire effect." When people's core beliefs are challenged with contradictory evidence, their brains often respond by strengthening the original belief. It’s a defense mechanism.
So, what do you actually say?
Stop lead-in sentences with "Actually..." or "The truth is..." Instead, try starting with curiosity. "I’ve heard that perspective, but I’m curious—how does that specifically affect your daily life?" It sounds simple, but it shifts the conversation from abstract talking points (which are basically scripts provided by cable news) to personal experience. Personal experience is much harder to argue with.
If they bring up the economy, don't just rattle off GDP numbers. Most people don't feel the GDP. They feel the price of eggs. Acknowledge that. "Yeah, things are expensive right now, and it’s stressing everyone out." Once you find that tiny sliver of common ground, the defensive walls start to crumble just a little bit. You aren't "the enemy" anymore; you're just another person who thinks eggs cost too much.
Navigating the Policy Minefield: What to Say to a Trumper About Specific Issues
When you're figuring out what to say to a trumper about the big stuff—immigration, the environment, or the legal cases—you have to decide what your goal is. Are you trying to change a mind, or are you just trying to maintain a relationship? If it's the latter, the best strategy is often "The Pivot."
Let’s talk about the "Deep State" or election integrity. These are high-emotion topics. Instead of calling them "conspiracy theories," which is a total conversation-killer, ask about the outcome they want.
"I think we both want elections that everyone can trust, right?"
Most will say yes.
"So, what specific security measures do you think would make you feel 100% confident?"
This forces the conversation into specifics rather than vague slogans. It moves from "everything is rigged" to "I think we need more paper trails." You can work with paper trails. You can’t work with "everything is rigged."
The "I See It Differently" Technique
Sometimes, you just can't find common ground. That's okay. You’re allowed to disagree. But there is a way to do it that doesn't end in a slammed door.
Use the "I" statement, but keep it grounded in values.
"I see it differently because I value [X]."
For example: "I hear that you're worried about national security. For me, I’m really focused on the humanitarian side of the border because of my faith/background/values. It’s a tough balance, isn't it?"
By framing it as a conflict of values rather than a conflict of "I’m right and you’re an idiot," you keep the door open. You aren't conceding. You’re just showing your work. It’s much harder for someone to attack your personal values than it is for them to attack a talking point they saw on X or Facebook.
Understanding the "Vibe" Over the "Policy"
To understand what to say to a trumper, you have to understand that for many, Trump isn't a policy platform. He’s a middle finger to a system they feel has ignored them for forty years.
📖 Related: Henley Shirts for Men: Why This Underrated Layer Is Better Than a T-Shirt
Sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild wrote a brilliant book called Strangers in Their Own Land. She spent years in Louisiana trying to understand the "Great Paradox"—why people support politicians whose policies might actually hurt their local environment or healthcare. She found what she calls the "Deep Story." It’s a narrative of people waiting in line for the American Dream, only to see others "cut in line" (immigrants, minorities, etc.) aided by the government.
Whether you agree with that story or not (and there are plenty of factual reasons to dispute it), that is the feeling behind the vote.
If you address the feeling, you get further.
"It sounds like you feel like the system is rigged against people who work hard."
When someone feels heard, they lower their guard. They might even listen to your "Deep Story" in return. This isn't about being "weak" or "giving in." It’s about tactical empathy. You’re using empathy as a tool to keep the lines of communication from being cut entirely.
When to Walk Away (The Silent Option)
Honestly? Sometimes the best thing to say is absolutely nothing.
Not every comment needs a rebuttal.
If the conversation is turning into a series of insults, or if you feel your blood pressure hitting dangerous levels, it's time to exit. You aren't going to save democracy over a lukewarm appetizer at a suburban chain restaurant.
🔗 Read more: Cal State Northridge Campus: What Nobody Tells You About the Valley’s Massive Hub
Try this: "I don't think we're going to see eye-to-eye on this today, and I value our friendship too much to get into a fight about it. Let’s talk about [the local sports team/your kids/the weather]."
It’s a boundary. Boundaries are healthy. If they keep pushing, you repeat the boundary. "I'm not talking about politics right now." It's firm, it's clear, and it prevents the relationship from being collateral damage in a political war.
Real-World Examples of Phrases That Work
- When they mention "Fake News": "There is definitely a lot of conflicting info out there. Where do you go when you want to find the raw data?"
- When they say "He tells it like it is": "He definitely has a unique way of speaking. What's the main thing he says that resonates most with you?"
- When things get heated: "Hey, we've known each other for ten years. We're more than just our votes. Let's take a breather."
Actionable Steps for Your Next Conversation
If you're heading into a situation where you know politics will come up, don't wing it. Having a plan makes you feel more in control and less reactive.
1. Set your "Success Metric" before you walk in.
If your goal is "make them admit they were wrong," you will fail. 100%. If your goal is "listen for three minutes without interrupting," or "share one personal concern without getting angry," you can actually achieve that.
2. Listen for the "Under-Feeling."
People rarely argue about what they’re actually arguing about. If they’re shouting about the border, they might actually be worried about their job security or their kids' future. If you can address the worry instead of the border wall, the conversation changes.
3. Use the "Tell Me More" rule.
Before you respond to a provocation, say "Tell me more about why you feel that way." It gives you time to breathe and forces them to move past the slogan into actual reasoning (which is often where people realize their own arguments are a bit thin).
4. Keep it local.
National politics is designed to be polarizing. Local politics—like the pothole on 5th Street or the new school board taxes—is where things get real. It’s harder to be a partisan caricature when you’re talking about the specific park down the street.
5. Know your "Hard Outs."
Decide in advance which topics are non-negotiable for you. If a conversation crosses into hate speech or personal attacks, have your exit line ready and use it. "I’m not okay with that kind of language, so I’m going to head out now." No drama, just a boundary.
Interacting with people who have vastly different worldviews is exhausting. It takes a lot of emotional labor. But if we all stop talking, the divide only gets wider. You don't have to change the world; you just have to manage the person sitting across from you without losing your own sense of peace. Sometimes, that's the biggest win you can get.