New Castle, New Hampshire is tiny. It’s basically a cluster of historic homes and narrow roads anchored by one of the most imposing hotels on the Eastern Seaboard. If you’ve ever driven toward the coast and seen those massive red towers rising over the water, you know exactly what I’m talking about. Inside that grand "Grande Dame" of hotels is Salt Kitchen & Bar Wentworth by the Sea, and honestly, it’s a bit of a contradiction.
Usually, when you walk into a Marriott-managed Opal Collection property that’s been around since 1874, you expect a certain level of stuffiness. You expect white tablecloths that feel like they’ve been starched into submission and servers who treat you like you’re about to be knighted.
Salt isn't really that.
👉 See also: Why the Finger Lakes Wine Festival is the One Event You Can't Skip This Year
It’s posh, sure. The dining room is centered under this massive, gorgeous domed ceiling that looks like it belongs in a European capital. But the vibe? It’s surprisingly relaxed. They’ve managed to strip away the pretension while keeping the luxury. It’s the kind of place where you can order a $120 bottle of wine but still feel okay laughing a little too loud at the bar.
What Actually Happens in the Kitchen
The name isn't just a marketing gimmick. They really lean into the brine.
Executive Chef Lee Slaninko and the culinary team have built a menu that focuses heavily on "land and sea," which sounds like every other restaurant on the New Hampshire Seacoast, but the execution is different here. They use a lot of salt-curing and pickling techniques that you don't see at your standard tourist trap in downtown Portsmouth.
Let’s talk about the Charcuterie. It’s probably the best way to see what the kitchen is actually doing. They aren't just buying pre-sliced meat. They’re doing the work in-house. You’ll get these thin, translucent slices of prosciutto or spicy coppa paired with house-made pickles that have enough vinegar kick to wake you up.
And the seafood. Man.
If you’re at Salt Kitchen & Bar Wentworth by the Sea, you’re probably looking for the raw bar. The oysters are usually sourced from right down the road—think Great Bay or Hampton Harbor. They taste like the Atlantic. Cold, metallic, and incredibly clean.
The Famous Domed Dining Room
You can't talk about this place without talking about the architecture. The original hotel was a wreck in the 1980s. It almost got torn down. When they renovated it, they kept the "Old World" soul but modernized the interior.
The dining room at Salt is circular. It creates this weirdly intimate acoustic environment where, despite the high ceilings, you don't feel like you’re sitting in a gymnasium. The lighting is low. The colors are muted—lots of grays, blues, and creams that reflect the ocean outside the windows. It’s a masterclass in coastal interior design that avoids the "shabby chic" anchor-and-rope clichés.
Why the Bar is the Secret Move
Sometimes the main dining room feels like "an event." Maybe it's an anniversary or a high-stakes business dinner. But the bar area? That’s where the locals actually go.
It’s comfortable. The bar stools are heavy, the bartenders know how to make a proper Negroni without looking up a recipe, and the menu is a bit more approachable. You can get a burger that actually tastes like high-quality beef rather than a frozen patty.
The cocktail program is surprisingly experimental for a hotel bar. They do a lot of infusions. You might find a gin drink with elderflower and fresh-slapped mint, or a bourbon-based "New Castle" twist that uses bitters you’ve never heard of. It’s refined. It's thoughtful.
The Reality of Dining at a Historic Landmark
Let’s be real for a second: dining here isn't cheap. You’re paying for the view, the history, and the fact that you’re sitting in a building where world leaders signed the Treaty of Portsmouth in 1905.
Sometimes, because it’s a high-volume hotel restaurant, the service can feel a little stretched during the peak summer months. If there’s a massive wedding in the ballroom and the hotel is at 100% capacity, your steak might take an extra five minutes. That’s just the reality of a resort operation.
But does it matter when you’re looking out at the marina? Probably not.
The menu changes seasonally. In the winter, it gets heavy and comforting—think short ribs braised in red wine until they basically turn into silk. In the summer, it’s all about lightness. Crudo, citrus, salads that actually taste like they came out of the ground that morning.
📖 Related: Weather at Cape Canaveral Florida: What Most People Get Wrong
The Brunch Situation
If you want to experience Salt Kitchen & Bar Wentworth by the Sea without the $200 dinner bill, go for brunch.
It’s legendary in the Portsmouth area. They do the whole spread. Omelets made to order, smoked salmon, pastries that are actually flaky. It’s a chaotic, beautiful scene of families and vacationers fueled by mimosas.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
Don't just show up and expect a table by the window.
- Book through OpenTable early. If you want a weekend dinner slot, you need to be looking two weeks out, especially in July or August.
- Request the "Dome" seating. If it’s your first time, you want to be under that ceiling. It’s part of the experience.
- Park at the bottom. The valet is convenient, but the walk up the hill from the lower lot gives you the best view of the hotel’s architecture.
- Check the Marina bar. In the summer, they sometimes have outdoor seating options that are even more casual than the indoor bar.
- Ask about the daily catch. They often have off-menu fish arrivals from the local piers that are fresher than anything on the printed page.
The real draw of Salt isn't just the food. It's the feeling that you’re part of a long timeline of New England history. You're eating in a place that has survived fires, neglect, and the changing whims of travel for over a century. That adds a layer of flavor you just can't get at a strip-mall bistro.
💡 You might also like: Taking the Boston to Buffalo Train: What Most People Get Wrong
Go for the oysters. Stay for the view of the masts swaying in the harbor. Leave with a deep appreciation for why "The Wentworth" is still the crown jewel of the New Hampshire coast.
Next Steps for Your Visit:
- Check the current seasonal menu on the official Wentworth by the Sea website to see the latest "Land and Sea" rotations.
- If you're staying locally, take the "Little Harbor Loop" trail hike before dinner; it ends right near the hotel and builds a serious appetite.
- Dress code is "Resort Casual"—you don't need a tie, but leave the flip-flops in the car if you're heading to the main dining room.